Tolkien's illustration from The Hobbit Read as much as you can for Thursday's class, at least to around Chapter 9, though feel free to go further as well. Here are some ideas to consider... * How equipped are the hobbits for the dangers of the outer world? How do they respond to the dangers in the Old Forest? * One of the most controversial figures in the LOTR trilogy is the strange creature of the forest, Tom Bombadil. What kind of figure is he, or what characters from other stories/legends might he remind you of? Also...why did the movies leave him completely out of the story? * How do the songs/poetry of different characters contrast with one another: for example, Frodo's songs and Gandalf's poem (in the letter)? * Why doesn't Tom disappear when he puts on the Ring? And in general, why is he so unaffected by it? Does this seem to contradict Gandalf's explanation in the earlier chapters, or the fact that it is the One Ring, created by Sauron? * Related to t...
For Tuesday: Tolkien, The Fellowship of the Ring, Chapters 3-6 (at least--feel free to go further or stop for rest a bit sooner)
Edward Burne-Jones, The Love Song (1868-77) Answer TWO of the following: Q1: Colin Wilson, in his article on Tolkien (quoted in the handout I gave you on Thursday), writes that "[Tolkien] dislikes the modern world, and like Eliot or Yeats, is allowing this negative feeling to trigger a creative response…In fact, like The Waste Land , it is at once an attack on the modern world and a credo, a manifesto." Where do we see this through Chapter 6 of the book? How is Tolkien creating a sort of 'credo' to the natural world, as opposed to the more orderly, mechanical world of man (or even, in a sense, the mundane world of the hobbits)? Q2: When asked about the elves, Sam responds that "They are quite different from what I expected--so old and young, and so gay and sad, as it were" (Ch.4). How does Tolkien depict the elves in these early chapters, and how does he contrast them to the hobbits? Related to this, why couldn't he have told the story through the eyes o...