Edward Burne-Jones, The Love Song (1868-77) Answer TWO of the following: Q1: Colin Wilson, in his article on Tolkien (quoted in the handout I gave you on Thursday), writes that "[Tolkien] dislikes the modern world, and like Eliot or Yeats, is allowing this negative feeling to trigger a creative response…In fact, like The Waste Land , it is at once an attack on the modern world and a credo, a manifesto." Where do we see this through Chapter 6 of the book? How is Tolkien creating a sort of 'credo' to the natural world, as opposed to the more orderly, mechanical world of man (or even, in a sense, the mundane world of the hobbits)? Q2: When asked about the elves, Sam responds that "They are quite different from what I expected--so old and young, and so gay and sad, as it were" (Ch.4). How does Tolkien depict the elves in these early chapters, and how does he contrast them to the hobbits? Related to this, why couldn't he have told the story through the eyes o...
NOTE: Reading the "Prologue" is suggested but optional, since it only delves into the background of the various races in the book, most notably, the Hobbits. It's not necessary to read this, but you might find it fascinating, especially if you're already a fan of the LOTR films. However, if you've never watched them, it could be too much information, and it arguably detracts from the story itself. Feel free to go right into Chapter 1 if you like. Answer TWO of the following as always: Q1: How do the hobbits view Gandalf and much of the outside world? Even though they live in an enchanted realm where elves, dwarves, trolls, etc., exist, what is their attitude toward much of it? Related to this, why might it be important to begin Tolkien's story here, rather than in a more enchanted place among the elves, or with Gandalf himself? Q2: Bilbo, though a relatively minor character in this book, was the protagonist of Tolkien's earlier work, The Hobbit , and h...